Should it have passed?

[R13]

There will be no Facebook shaming of those arrested for driving under the influence by posting their mug shots, the council of a California beach city decided late Tuesday.

While drinking and driving is a huge problem in Huntington Beach, aka "Surf City," the council gave a "no" vote to their colleague's proposal to put repeat offenders' mug shots on the police department's Facebook page.

Devin Dwyer wanted to put the information on the Facebook page, saying before the meeting, "If it takes shaming people to save lives, I am willing to do it ... I'm hoping it prevents others from getting behind the wheel and getting inebriated."

During discussion Tuesday, council member Kevin Bohr said the proposal "might be well-meaning, but it is misguided, misdirected ... It's the wrong tool at the wrong time."

City officials noted that arrest information is already available online via the police department's website.

Council member Connie Boardman was perhaps the most eloquent when she spoke of the repercussions such an action could have.

"I appreciate council members Dwyer's efforts to deal with this serious problem of drunk driving and thinking creatively," she said. "But, "repeat drunk drivers, well ... they're addicts; they're alcoholics, and putting their picture on Facebook is not going to stop them from drinking. But what it will do is humiliate their parents and terribly embarrass their children.

"Children of alcoholics live in a private hell as it is, and I don't want this city to make it any worse for them," she said. "You know how savvy kids are with Facebook. A picture that appears on the police department's Facebook page is not going to stay there. It's going to be on the home pages and (Facebook) 'walls' of hundreds of kids at the high school or middle school where the children of that alcoholic go. These kids may have real successful in hiding a secret that they're deeply ashamed of, and we've just outed them. And I just don't want to contribute to that."

Technolog - Facebook shaming for drunk drivers voted down

[1inStripes]

I see both sides of the arguement put forth. That would be a tough vote IMO.

[steer]

I'm not sure I'd vote yes for that. You really have to take those kids into mind. They already have to deal with the fact mom/dad are alcoholics, and now they'd have their image blasted on a facebook page that their friends could see.
That's a really, really, really tough decision.

[centennialdawg]

I think that Kingsport and maybe Bristol, Tn do this now. I do know that they post them in the online Timesnews editions. Just point to new, then when the subheadings come up, click on Aressted.

[burton2019]

I think that Kingsport and maybe Bristol, Tn do this now. I do know that they post them in the online Timesnews editions. Just point to new, then when the subheadings come up, click on Aressted.

They do. This should have passed. If your dumbass gets behind a wheel drunk and driving, endangering everyone else's lives then you should get a pic of your ignorant ass all over the web.

[steer]

They do. This should have passed. If your dumbass gets behind a wheel drunk and driving, endangering everyone else's lives then you should get a pic of your ignorant ass all over the web.

I agree to an extent. What if the person has kids, and their friends get on and see that picture, and they have to suffer because of the parents. That's the big thing.

[SWVA-Football]

I'm not sure I'd vote yes for that. You really have to take those kids into mind. They already have to deal with the fact mom/dad are alcoholics, and now they'd have their image blasted on a facebook page that their friends could see.
That's a really, really, really tough decision.

I agree completely. That's something most people probably don't even consider.